Toyo Open Country M/T vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires

When it comes to choosing mud terrain tires under a budget Toyo and Nexen tire brands are sure to cross your mind as they have a solid lineup of highly capable, reliable, and durable tire lines. Your off-road adventures can be impacted significantly if you miss choosing the right mud-terrain tire. Two popular contenders in this category are the Toyo Open Country M/T and the Nexen Roadian MTX. Both tires are designed to tackle challenging terrains, from rocky trails to muddy paths, but they each offer distinct features and performance characteristics.

The Toyo Open Country M/T has a long-standing reputation for its exceptional off-road grip, durability, and relatively quiet on-road manners for a mud-terrain tire. It's often a favorite among serious off-road enthusiasts who demand top-tier performance. The Nexen Roadian MTX, on the other hand, presents a more budget-friendly option while still promising aggressive off-road capabilities and a stylish appearance. It aims to balance off-road prowess with on-road comfort at a less aggressive price point.

This comparison will talk about their tread patterns, rubber compounds, performance in different terrains, noise levels, and overall value to help you determine which tire best suits your needs and budget. We'll explore how these two mud-terrain tires stack up against each other by doing a Toyo Open Country M/T vs. Nexen Roadian MTX tires comparison based on our proprietary SimpleScore.

Toyo Open Country M/T tires

Designed for 4x4s, Jeeps, lifted trucks, and SUVs, the Open Country M/T is a popular tire name among off-road enthusiasts in the US. With an aggressive tread pattern, the Toyo mud-terrain tire features hooked-shaped blocks and deep siping that cling to the surface and provide excellent grip and traction in different conditions of mud, dirt, sand, gravel, snow, and rocks. While the staggered sidewall design offers improved grip and traction in deep mud, dirt, and rocks, the robust polyester construction and high turn-up enhance impact resistance, handling, and durability.

The Toyo tire’s open scalloped shoulder blocks not only improve grip and traction in challenging conditions but also have inbuilt ejectors to push snow, debris, mud, and stones out of the tread to maintain a consistent grip and resist any damage. Backed by a standard material warranty, the Open Country M/T is available with a 500-mile/45-day trial offer for complete peace of mind.

The Toyo Open Country M/T scores a near-perfect 9.3 out of 10, promising outstanding grip, traction, durability, and tread life.

Get Toyo Open Country M/T tires at the best deals for your vehicle here.

Nexen Roadian MTX tires

The Nexen Roadian MTX, a rugged mud-terrain tire, caters to drivers seeking a balance of aggressive off-road performance and on-road comfort. Designed for SUVs, pickup trucks, and Jeeps, the Roadian MTX boasts robust construction and an appealing design, making it a popular choice for those wanting to enhance their vehicle's appearance as well as its capabilities. Its aggressive tread pattern, featuring large, staggered blocks and a dual sidewall design (machine and beast), is engineered to provide excellent traction in challenging terrains like mud, dirt, and rocks.

Beyond its off-road prowess, the Roadian MTX also aims to deliver a relatively quiet and comfortable ride on paved roads, a crucial factor for many drivers who use their vehicles both on and off the trail. While it may not have the same long-standing reputation as some other mud-terrain tires, the Nexen Roadian MTX has gained recognition for its blend of performance, aesthetics, and competitive price point.

With an 8.2 average SimpleScore, the Nexen Roadian MTX promises adequate traction, grip, and durability in mud, sand, rocks, and snow.

Get Nexen Roadian MTX tires at the best deals for your vehicle here.

Toyo Open Country M/T vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires on traction

Mud-terrain tires are preferred for their superior grip and traction in mud, rocks, and sand. With a decent void ratio, Toyo and Nexen mud-terrain tires offer reliable on and off-road performance.

With an incredible 9.7 traction score, the Toyo Open Country M/T features an aggressive tread design with deep siping and hooked-shaped blocks which provide extra biting edges for excellent grip and traction in difficult terrains such as mud, dirt, snow, gravel, and rocks. The sidewall design with scalloped shoulders further improves grip in deep snow and mud by clearing debris for consistent traction on and off the road.

Scoring an 8.1, the Nexen Roadian MTX is more in line with the off-road traction. Featuring large tread blocks and a high void ratio, the Nexen mud-terrain tire has self-cleaning properties that help remove mud, dirt, and rocks from the tread for consistent grip in different driving conditions. The dual sidewall design of the “Beast” option features more aggressive sidewall lugs that enhance traction in loose terrain and deep ruts.

The Toyo Open Country M/T is way too ahead of the Nexen Roadian MTX in the traction tussle.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country M/T

Toyo Open Country M/T vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires on durability

Mud-terrain tires are highly durable thanks to the reinforced material used in their construction. How good the Toyo and Nexen tires are when it comes to tackling and crushing gravel, rocks, and mud? Let’s check their durability performance.

The Toyo mud-terrain tire continues to impress as it scores yet another superb score of 9.4 in durability. Thanks to the rugged polyester construction and high turn-up, the tire provides high resistance to cuts, chips, punctures, and abrasions along with extra strength against impacts. Moreover, the self-cleaning tread design limits the housing of mud, stones, and rocks to resist stone drilling. Driving habits and conditions also influence the durability of these tires.

Scoring 8.3 in durability, the Nexen Roadian MTX features a 3-ply carcass construction or a three-layer sidewall reinforcement for enhanced hauling capabilities and extra protection against cuts, punctures, and impacts crucial for off-road environments. The rim protector bar (on sizes 20 inches and larger) shields the rim from damage due to curbs or rocks. However, like most mud-terrain tires, tread life can be influenced by driving habits and terrain types.

With an excellent score, the Toyo Open Country M/T cruises ahead of the Nexen Roadian MTX in the traction race.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country M/T

Toyo Open Country M/T vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires on longevity

Mud-terrain tires are more towards durability and performance than longevity, considering the abuse they have to go through in mud, dirt, rocks, and snow. The Open Country M/T and the Roadian MTX do not come with a mileage warranty, just like most mud-terrain tires out there. Let’s see how they perform in longevity.

The Toyo Open Country M/T is known to offer incredible tread life, one of its unique selling points among its admirers. Scoring an 8.8 in longevity, the Toyo mud-terrain tire features a sturdy construction and a tough rubber compound that not only aids in balancing driving pressure throughout the tire but also resists uneven wear and tear leading to a decent tread life.

On the other hand, the Nexen scores an 8.5 in longevity. Tailored more towards off-road use than on-road driving, the Roadian MTX has a robust construction and aggressive tread pattern that encourages regular wear while resisting tears, cuts, and punctures on and off the road. The overall mileage of the Nexen mud-terrain tire is acceptable considering the price point segment it falls in.

While the battle closes in, yet again, it’s the Toyo Open Country M/T that finishes as a winner in tread life too.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country M/T

When to use each

Mud-terrain tires feature large tread blocks and staggered sidewall designs for maximum traction in challenging terrains like mud, gravel, sand, dirt, snow, and rocks. While their high void ratio facilitates quick tread cleaning for consistent grip, their cut- and chip-resistant compound enhances durability and extends tire life.

However, if you plan to do more on-road driving than off-road rounds, all-terrain tires are more suitable as they are quiet on the road, offer comfortable ride quality, and last significantly longer than mud-terrain tires.

While the Toyo Open Country M/T should be chosen if you prefer exceptional on and off-road performance, the Nexen Roadian MTX should be preferred only for off-road performance and acceptable on-road drivability.

Which one should you choose?

To sum up, the Toyo Open Country M/T beats the Nexen Roadian MTX on all fronts – traction, durability, and longevity. However, each tire has its unique specialties which may appeal to a particular segment of buyers. Let’s check the last crucial bit, which is often the decider in sealing a deal, the price!

Comparing the prices for the LT285/65R18 tire size, the Toyo Open Country M/T costs around $436 per tire while four such tires cost $1744. Similarly, the Nexen Roadian MTX costs about $370 per tire, with four costing $1480 (a difference of $264).

Based on SimpleScore, you can choose the Toyo Open Country M/T if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Jeep Wrangler, Nissan Titan, and Ford F-150.
• Want a highly durable (9.4 vs 8.3) mud-terrain tire
• Prefer exceptional grip and traction (9.7 vs 8.1)
• Want a long-lasting tire (8.8 vs 8.5)

You can go for the Nexen Roadian MTX if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Jeep Wrangler, Toyota Tacoma, and RAM 3500.
• Want an affordable yet capable mud-terrain tire
• Prefer a more appealing tread design (subjective though)

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.